In the area of indirect taxation, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) has become a revolutionary force that has altered not just the fiscal landscape of India but also that of many other countries. This in-depth examination carefully examines both the benefits and drawbacks of the GST to shed light on the significant impacts it has had on economies, companies, and people. The GST, at its heart, represents a fundamental shift in taxation and serves as a powerful counterbalance to the complex web of municipal, state, and federal taxes. Rather, it institutes a universal tax system that is simpler and covers both commodities and services. Ever since its introduction, GST has been the focus of extensive research and a heated topic of discussion among professionals and stakeholders. This blog discusses in brief about the different Advantages and Disadvantages of GST (Goods and Service Tax).
The goal of these talks is to shed light on the whole range of benefits and drawbacks related to this tax revolution. In actuality, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) has benefits as well as drawbacks in the countries where it has been imposed, such as India. Examining both sides of the issue is essential to understanding this important tax reform.
Types of GST
Four main types of Goods and Services Tax (GST) apply to different transactions and circumstances inside a country’s tax structure. These four GST variants encourage fair tax burden sharing and simplified tax management. To elucidate each of these further:
1. Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST):
The federal government collects the CGST component of GST on interstate sales of goods and services. Put more simply, CGST is a tax levied by the federal government on purchases made inside a single state or union territory. The CGST generates revenue for the national government.
2. State Goods and Services Tax (SGST):
State governments collect SGST, which is the equivalent of CGST, on transactions that occur inside their borders. It guarantees the states receive a portion of the GST income. Both SGST and CGST are imposed on transactions that take place within a state, and the money collected goes to the central and state governments in that state.
3. Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST):
When a transaction involves the transfer of goods or services between other states or union territories, the IGST is applicable. In certain situations, the central government imposes a single tax known as the IGST. The center and the consuming state then split the revenue that was made.
4. Union Territory Goods and Services Tax (UTGST):
Similar to SGST, UTGST is only applicable to union territories without their legislature. The federal government has direct control over these union territories. Even union territories will receive a portion of the GST money generated inside their borders thanks to UTGST. Together, these four forms of GST make up a nation’s GST structure, which guarantees an extensive and effective tax system. Depending on the specifics and location of the transaction, they aid in preventing double taxation and guarantee that the federal and state governments each receive an equitable portion of tax money.
The Advantages of GST
Let’s delve into a detailed paraphrasing of the pros of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and its positive impacts on businesses and the economy:
-
Elimination of Cascading Tax Effect:
Consolidating several taxes into a single system and doing away with the intricate network of levies that were in place before is one of the most prominent benefits of the Goods and Services Tax (GST). The efficiency of tax processing is increased by this simplicity. For example, before the introduction of the products and Services Tax (GST), a hotel owner was required to pay Value Added Tax (VAT) on sales of both products and services, which had the effect of cascading taxes. The “tax on tax” effect is removed by CST, which lowers tax obligations.
-
Enhanced Threshold Limit:
Before the introduction of the GST, companies had to pay VAT if their annual revenue surpassed a state-specific level. Nevertheless, the threshold level was raised to 20 lakhs after the GST was implemented, an increase of 15 lakhs. Small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) benefit greatly from this higher threshold, which lowers their tax liabilities.
-
Minimized Compliances:
Administrative complexity resulted from the need for separate compliances for every kind of tax in the pre-GST era. For example, depending on the kind of corporate entity, service tax returns were submitted either quarterly or monthly, whereas excise tax returns were filed monthly. This was made simpler by GST, which only required taxpayers to file returns once, irrespective of the form of tax.
-
Composition Scheme:
Businesses with an annual turnover between 20 lakhs and 75 lakhs might reduce their taxable revenue using the Composition Scheme offered by GST. This plan reduces the tax burden by allowing for a constant tax rate. However, there are certain restrictions attached to it. These include limited application to businesses that are solely focused on selling goods (i.e., not services), non-applicability to interstate supply businesses or e-commerce, limitations on the amount of taxes that can be collected from customers, and different tax rates for manufacturers, dealers, and restaurant owners.
-
Smooth Online Processing:
One major benefit of the GST adoption was the ability to process taxes online. The GST Portal has a user-friendly design that makes it simple for taxpayers to register, log in, and submit returns. Startups have benefited most from this since it encourages openness between federal and state tax authorities.
-
Warehousing for E-commerce and Logistics Companies:
Previously, logistics companies established several warehouses in different states to offset state entrance fees and Central Sales Tax (CST). As a result, warehouse utilization was not at its best. Logistics and e-commerce firms can strategically locate facilities with GST, cutting down on needless warehousing expenses. Furthermore, the GST has improved accountability by bringing previously unorganized industries like construction and textiles under its jurisdiction.
-
Inclusion of E-commerce Operators:
E-commerce merchants were unclearly defined by law before to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and faced different state-by-state taxation policies. GST has made it easier for e-commerce companies to comply with tax laws by clearly defining them and introducing special allowances for them.
All of these benefits of GST work together to simplify tax procedures, lessen complexity, and make doing business in India easier. They have promoted growth and openness inside the Indian tax system, especially benefiting startups, e-commerce operators, small and medium-sized businesses, and logistics firms.
The Disadvantages of GST
Here are some of the important disadvantages of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) along with its potential negative effects on businesses:
-
Increased Operational Costs:
Businesses need to upgrade their accounting systems with GST-compliant software or Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software to comply with the GST. Such software can be costly, and to use it successfully, one needs to be well-trained. This would require adds to a company’s expenses. Additionally, Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs) now have to pay more for operating expenditures due to GST compliance. To handle the difficulty of GST legislation, SMBs may need to hire professionals.
• Higher Tax Liability for SMBs:
Under the previous tax regime, enterprises with annual revenues of over Rs. 1.5 crore were exempt from excise duty. With the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), companies that generate over Rs. 40 lakhs in revenue annually must now pay taxes. SMBs now face a higher tax burden as a result of this lower threshold.
-
Difficult Compliance Requirements:
Every business is required under GST to register on the GST portal in the state in which they conduct business. It takes extra effort to complete the registration process and maintain the resulting records, invoices, and returns. It has increased the administrative load on firms, especially on startups. In addition, some difficulties with compliance because of certain Indian states’ lack of technological capability.
-
Penalties for Non-Compliance:
All businesses must register on the GST portal. There are repercussions for breaking the rules. Many Micro, Small, and Medium-Sized Enterprises (MSMEs) may find the GST tax regime too complex to comprehend, necessitating the hiring of experts or the use of the Internet. Even with the advent of internet systems that enable small and medium-sized enterprises to offer free digital invoices that conform with GST, penalties for non-compliance still exist.
All of these drawbacks add to the difficulties that businesses—especially small and medium-sized enterprises—have adjusting to the GST system. Under the new tax framework, firms face challenges including increasing operational costs, tax liabilities, onerous compliance requirements, and possible fines for noncompliance.
End Notes!
In many other countries besides India, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) has completely changed the indirect taxation environment. It is clear from weighing the benefits and drawbacks of the GST that this tax reform has had a significant impact on people’s lives, businesses, and economies.
Fundamentally, indirect taxation has been altered in India and other nations by the dynamic and ever-evolving tax reform known as the Goods and Services Tax (GST). By being aware of its benefits and drawbacks, we can work together to maximize its potential and resolve its drawbacks to eventually strive for a more effective and fair tax system that serves both individuals and corporations. The GST is still in its early stages, and its effects on economies and societies will certainly change as time goes on.
